Prominent poker professional Phil Ivey and a colleague broke the rules, but didn’t cheat, a federal judge ruled on Friday. In dispute is how they won Baccarat nearly $ 10 million playing at Atlantic City’s Borgata casino.
Ivey is a nine-time World Series of Poker winner.
US District Court Judge Noel Hillman said the two failed to fulfill their obligation to follow gambling regulations on four occasions in 2012 by having dealers in Borgata set up a Baccarat card so they can find out what kind of card is coming next (due to printing defects in the cards) visit KudaQQ .
By shifting the odds in their favor, they violated the New Jersey Casino Control Act, the judge ruled. He dumped the accusation by Borgata that the couple was committing fraud. The casino now has 20 days to describe the damage it says was sustained.
“Borgata and Ivey had the same goal when they entered into their arrangement: to profit from the other,” wrote the judge.
Borgata claims that the pair exploited flawed cards which allowed them to sequence and arrange good cards. Casinos say this technique, called edge sorting, violates state casino gambling regulations. But Ivey insists his victory is only the result of skill and good observation.
Borgata claims the cards used in the game were damaged because the pattern on the back was not uniform. Ivey said he only paid attention to things that could be observed by anyone playing.
The judge said that Ivey and co-player Cheng Yin Sun instructed the dealer to arrange the cards in a certain way, which is permitted under the rules of the game, after Sun noticed the difference in minutes on them. But he decided the act violated the state’s Casino Control Act and their contractual obligation to abide by it in casino gambling.
“But while Ivey and Sun’s cunning and skill did not violate the rules of Baccarat,” the judge wrote, “what distinguishes Ivey and Sun’s actions from the ruse of maneuvers in other games is that they violate the rules of gambling as defined in this country.”